=====================================================================
ACHA PEACE BULLETIN
http://www.groups.yahoo.com/group/ACHAPeaceBulletin
=====================================================================
A
publication of Association for Communal Harmony in Asia (ACHA)
www.asiapeace.org & www.indiapakistanpeace.org
Editor: Pritam K. Rohila,
PhD asiapeace@comcast.net
Subscription
is free.
To SUBSCRIBE, email a request to ACHAPeaceBulletin-subscribe@yahoogroups.com
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email the request to ACHAPeaceBulletin-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
Volume
XII, No. 9:
______________________________________________________________________________
CONTENTS
EDITORIAL
*We Shall Fight No More, Pritam K. Rohila, Ph.D.
BOOKS
*Honour Killing:
Dilemma, Ritual, Understanding, Amir Hamid Jafri
*The Ulama, Islamic Ethics and Courts Under the
Mughals—Aurangzeb Revisited, M. L.
Bhatia
CONTESTS
*September 28 – October
5,
EDUCATION & TRAINING
*October
3 & 4,
*28
September - 20 December,
EDUCATION & TRAINING RESOURCES
EVENTS
*September
17-21, Caboolture to
*September
26-October 2,
*October
4-7, Koach,
*October 17,
*November 29-30, Ambala Cantt,
*
Religions
FELLOWSHIPS FOR
JOURNALISTS FROM
*March 15 -
JOBS, INTERNSHIPS &
VOLUNTEER PROGRAMS (FOR THE COMMON GOOD)
MEMBERS’ CORNER
PEACE & HARMONY NEWS FROM
PEACE & HARMONY NEWS FROM
PEACE PETITIONS
UPDATE:
UPDATE:
UPDATE:
* Humanitarian organisations have key role to play, Jehan Perera
_____________________________________________________________________________
EDITORIAL
*We Shall Fight No More, Pritam K. Rohila, Ph.D.
“Be
advised: We, the ordinary citizens of this Earth will no longer fight, support,
or otherwise engage in war or mortal conflict of any sort.”
This is a petition for peace,
which is being circulated by Neil Haddon.
It is addressed to the world leaders and global organizations.
“For thousands of years it
appears that mankind has been obsessed with war,” he writes. And the civilian,
non-combatant casualties of war have increased from less than 5 percent in the
First World War to 75 percent currently,
“Why does a species that has
learned to sail the seas in ships of steel, fly through the air like birds,
eradicate diseases, and beam sound and pictures around the planet, prove unable
to master the simple art of peaceful co-existence?” he laments.
Currently, tension between the
“Isn’t it time” Mr. Haddon
pleads, “to speak out for what the ordinary man or woman has come to know full
well, but our ‘leaders’ seem incapable of understanding: war solves nothing?” But
diplomacy, discussion, engagement to seek a win-win situation for the good of
all is the only solution to disagreement.
We are masters
of our own destiny, and another sound concept is, "If you are not happy with
the way your life is, change!"
“Well, I'm not
happy with the way our lives are at the moment,” Mr. Haddon declares. And therefore,
to focus on the positive, he has established this Petition for Peace at
http://www.gopetition.co.uk/online/21655.html
I urge you all
to sign this petition, and persuade your friends to do the same. As Mr. Haddon
suggests, “Every child, woman, and man will really benefit
from your support…Moreover, I know your deeds and actions influence
many brothers and sisters across the globe.”
If you wish to
discuss the matter with Mr. Neil Haddon you can reach him at wayshower@gmail.com
BOOKS
*Honour Killing: Dilemma, Ritual, Understanding, Amir Hamid Jafri,
Amir Hamid
Jafri, whom I salute for spelling his last name in the simplest possible form,
considering some very strange ways in which it is seen spelt, is truly a man of
many parts. He trained as an engineer, played cricket for the Engineering
University, Combined Universities, and Combined Services XI in Pakistan, joined
the EME Corps of the Pakistan Army, left to travel the world, drove a cab in
New York for over a decade while he studied theatre in the city's bohemian
district, Greenwich Village and moved on for another gig at graduate school at
the University of Oklahoma, where he completed his doctoral work in
communication. Since then he has taught a variety of subjects under the rubric
of rhetoric, communication, culture and gender.
Now, drawing from sacred texts and eminent philosophers and theorists from
various traditions, and extending on his doctoral research, Jafri has written a
scholarly book titled, Honour Killing: Dilemma, Ritual, Understanding, being
published by Oxford University Press. Sensational as it is, the subject has
been covered at length in popular national and international media, but this
work is a first of its kind, a seminal research and systematic exploration of
the gruesome practice in certain cultures where male agnates of a family kill
their women in order to restore what they consider their family honour.
What propelled Jafri into the research was the cold blooded murder of
29-year-old Samia Sarwar on in
Samia was killed by her parents because she was said to have brought
"shame to her family and tradition." A mother of two, Samia had been
seeking a divorce from her husband Imran, a doctor, on grounds of domestic
violence and his drug abuse. Since the family wanted no such thing, Samia had
sought help from lawyers Hina and Asma. In various quarters of Pakistani
culture, the killers were praised since they were said to have killed in
accordance with their tradition, which exempted the killing from the realm of
crime. Remarkably, Sen Ilyas Bilour, a senator from Samia's home
In the several languages and dialects spoken in
With meticulous interpretation of texts, data analysis and other evidence,
Jafri proves that, as viewed in the West and claimed by certain "discourse
communities" in Pakistan, honour killing is not an Islamic custom but one
that has often been co-opted as a rallying point by the fundamentalists in their
bid to rid Pakistan of "foreign ideological influences." Jafri writes
that the inability of the enforcing agencies to arrest the audacious
perpetrators and the paralysis of the national judicial system to enforce the
law are powerful messages to fellow citizens and the world about the
"true" identity of the state. While a segment of the population
perceives the act as pure and simple murder, others view it as an honest and
dutiful attempt at the re-ordination of the universe, a re-balancing of the
cosmos that can only be made possible by purging a family of profanity and
restoring its sacred nature.
For those who view it as their sacred duty, killing for the sake of individual
and collective honour is not a crime but a heroic act because only under
circumstances restored by such killings could an honourable life – the only
life worth living – be possible. Honour killing is not a clandestine activity
but a loud public proclamation in
Jafri notes that honour killing continues to some degree in certain Latin
American and
Demonstrating the interruption of an oppressive and hegemonic discourse in
Pakistan, among other evidence, Jafri reproduces Attiya Dawood's translation of
the Sindhi poem about a young girl that says it all: What is there to my
body?/Is it studded with diamonds or pearls?/My brother's eyes forever follow
me./My father's gaze guards me all the time,/Stern, angry./Then why do they
make me labour in the fields?/All day long, bear the heat and the sun,/Sweat
and toil and we tremble all day long,/ Not knowing who may cast a look upon
us./We stand accused, and condemned to be declared kari/ And murdered.
*The Ulama,
Islamic Ethics and Courts Under the Mughals—Aurangzeb Revisited, M. L. Bhatia,
Manak Publications, New Delhi, 2006, 255 Pages, ISBN: 81-7827-158-3, Rs. 650
Review by Yoginder Sikand ysikand@yahoo.com
Berated as a villain and a fiercely anti-Hindu fanatic by his Hindu critics and
lauded as a champion of Islam by his Muslim admirers, the Mughal Emperor
Aurangzeb was actually far more complex a person than either camp makes him out
to be. In a refreshing attempt to humanise his image, this book seeks to
discuss Aurangzeb's religious policies by setting them within a broader
political framework. Rather than being solely guided by religious beliefs, the
book shows that Aurangzeb's religious policies were a result of a complex
interplay of personal as well as political factors. In this way, the book
provides a far more nuanced picture of the Emperor than what both his vehement
critics and his passionate backers present.
Far from causing a radical break with Mughal precedent, Bhatia argues,
Aurangzeb's religious policies, in particular his attitude towards the orthodox
Sunni ulema, represent, in many
senses, a continuation of it. As before, under Aurangzeb, sections of the ulema
received generous royal support, and they, in turn, proved to be a major
ideological pillar for the regime. Although Aurangzeb was certainly more
generous with his patronage of the ulema than several of
his predecessors, he did not allow them to dictate state policies.
Though they were given prestige, the ulema remained, in the final analysis,
subservient to the state and lacked an effective independent voice to enforce
their views. While Aurangzeb sometimes sought their advice on matters of the
shariah, he often dispensed with their views
altogether, preferring his own opinions to theirs. As before, the shariah, in
the sense of fiqh or historical Muslim jurisprudence, remained only one,
although in some spheres major, source of law under Aurangzeb, and it was often
supplemented, even supplanted, by imperial edicts and customary laws, some of
which were directly in contravention of the shariah as the 'orthodox' Sunni
ulema viewed it.
Bhatia supplies numerous instances to substantiate this argument. Aurangzeb's
imprisonment of his own father and murder of his brothers, which brought him to
power, were, of course, just two of these instances, but there were others as
well. When the imperial qazi refused to read the khutba in his name, Aurangzeb
had him summarily dismissed, and, later, when the Shaikh ul-Islam refused to
supply him with a fatwa legitimising his plans to invade the Muslim kingdoms of
the
Yet, at the same time, Bhatia acknowledges that Aurangzeb did take certain other
steps that were, so he believes, calculated to win the approval the 'orthodox'
ulema. One of his major
achievements in this regard was to commission the compilation of a code of
Hanafi law, named after him as the Fatawa-e Alamgiri, the collective work of
several ulema. Bhatia opines that in itself this did not represent a major
development in Islamic law as it was simply a digest
of secondary sources by earlier ulema for the guidance of qazis or judges, and,
despite it, qazis continued to hand out judgments according to their own
understanding and interpretations of the shariah.
Other measures taken by Aurangzeb, viewed as either a result of his religious
zeal or an effort to win crucial ulema support, included the selective
destruction of Hindu temples, the
imposition of the jizya on Hindus, the resumption of some tax-free grants to
Hindus, the curbing of certain rituals at Sufi shrines and so on, all of these
passionately backed by leading sections of the court ulema. Bhatia argues that
some of these measures were only half-heartedly introduced and implemented.
Thus, typically, cases of temple destruction occurred not in times of peace but
in regions that had been newly conquered or where Aurangzeb had sent his forces
to put
down rebellions led by Hindu chieftains. At the same time as Aurangzeb forbade
the construction of new temples, he is also said to have granted tax-free lands
to some temple establishments and to have instructed his officials not to
harass the priests who were in-charge
of old temples.
Likewise, Bhatia points out, it was only twenty-two years after his ascent to
the throne that Aurangzeb decided to impose the jizya on the Hindus, and this
may have actually been a response to the outbreak of rebellions of the
Marathas, Sikhs, Jats and others. Certain classes of Hindus, including
government officials, were exempted from the jizya, while, at the same time,
Aurangzeb made arrangements for the zakat to be collected from Muslims. Bhatia
writes that 'It is also stated that long before jizya was imposed, Aurangzeb
had ordered the abolition of a number of unauthorised taxed which placed heavy
burden on the Hindus' (p.52). He admits that one of the aims of imposing the
jizya, as the court ulema saw it, was to degrade the Hindus, and this naturally
caused considerable ill-will and resentment among them. That the financial
aspect of the jizya was not seen by the ulema as equally important as its
symbolism is reflected in the fact that the total collection from the jizya was
only slightly more than the money spent on collecting it, with much of the
money collected going into the pockets of corrupt officials. And
as for the resumption of tax-free land grants to Hindu priests and yogis,
Bhatia writes that this was only a temporary measure in the wake of Hindu-led
rebellions and that when these subsided the edict was allowed, for all
practical purposes, to lapse.
Much of this book is devoted to a detailed discussion of the elaborate
hierarchy of court ulema under Aurangzeb. Starting from the Shaikh ul-Islam and
the chief imperial qazi in
But was this elaborate hierarchy of religious specialists, trained in the
shariah, truly able to function in the manner that is made out by pro-Aurangzeb
propagandists? Bhatia opines
that the system was riddled with corruption and inefficiency. May qazis were
indeed upright but many others were not, and some used their position to extort
money from the public. The muhtasibs were charged with enforcing Islamic laws
and morality, but were often unable to do
so, particularly when it came to local Muslim elites, many of who were given to
a life of wanton luxury, including usury, drinking and music, which the
'orthodox' Sunni ulema condemned.
Bhatia writes
that numerous Sufis protested against the harshness of the muhtasibs,
particularly on the issue of banning music. Despite the ulema's insistence on
the strict following of Islamic jurisprudence in matters related to revenue collection,
the traditional revenue system remained intact. Likewise, local caste
panchayats, even among local Muslim convert groups, continued to be allowed to
function and decided disputes on lines that sometimes contravened the shariah
as the court ulema understood it.
Despite stern opposition from the 'orthodox' ulema, partly for what these ulema
saw as some of their unwarranted beliefs and practices but also because of
jealousy owing to their mass support, popular Sufis, including those who
preached the doctrine of wahdat al-wujud or the
'unity of existence' and sought to stress the oneness of Hindus, Muslims and
others, continued to flourish. Furthermore, the 'orthodox' ulema, Bhatia
writes, were unable to present a united front, often at odds with each other
and riddled with internal jealousies and rivalries.
In other words, Bhatia argues—critiquing both those who demonise as well as
eulogise Aurangzeb for his religious policies—in the face of the various
political and other constraints
that Aurangzeb was confronted with, 'the idea of an Islamic state under Aurangzeb
remains no more than a mere fiction' (x).
Clumsy grammar and frequent repetitions mar the book, as do unnecessarily long
sections that could easily have been presented in a more concise fashion. Yet,
this book excels as a rare,
balanced portrayal of a much-discussed but still little- understood figure.
CONTESTS
*September 28
– October 5,
Entry forms and
more information available from www.gandhilibray.org, and Atul B.
Kothari, Director of Public Relations, 713-785-3900, e-mail: akothari@gandhilibrary.org
EDUCATION & TRAINING
*October 3 & 4,
*28 September - 20 December,
Stadtschlaining, Austria: PEACE AND CONFLICT RESOLUTION STUDYat the
European University Center for Peace Studies (EPU), Stadtschlaining, Austria
(www.epu.ac.at, epu@epu.ac.at, Tel +43-3355-2498-515
mornings.
The EPU program is designed to provide students with the intellectual
competence to analyze conflicts and their underlying causes, with practical
skills in conflict transformation and peacebuilding, and with the motivation to
do everything in their capacity to help create a better world.
More info from www.epu.ac.at or Anita Flasch, Administrative
Assistant epu@epu.ac.at, Tel +43-3355-2498-515
(Monday-Friday mornings) or Dr. Dietrich Fischer, Academic Director,
Tel+43-3355-20726 anytime.
EDUCATION
& TRAINING RESOURCES
http://www.psysr.org/about/committees/peace_education/
EVENTS
*September 17-21, Caboolture
to
by an Australian Gandhian,
Garwin Brown. The walk will start from Caboolture and end at
Garwin Brown was born on
*September 26-October 2,
Chandigarh, India: 3RD ANNUAL INDO-PAK STUDENTS PEACE CAMP, to promote
peace between Pakistan and India, is being organized at Chandigarh, by CYDA,
the Centre for Youth Development and
Activities, Sadikabad, Pakistan (www.cydapakistan.org). Intended for youth of age
15-26, the program will include a number of mixed group activities and
excursion trips in and around
Registration
must be completed by July 10. To request a registration application and
additional info contact info@cydapakistan.org. A
welcome pack with more details will be sent to the applicants upon confirmation
of their registration.
*October 4-7, Koach, Kerala,
India: SPIRITUALITY AND ENVIRONMENT is theme of the World Fellowship of
Inter-Religious Councils (WFIRC) Assembly 2008, at the Renewal Centre,Azad Road, Koach-682017 in Kerala,
India. Registration fee is Rs. 500 to meet the expenses, in part, of boarding
and lodging. More info from Justice P.K.Shamsuddin, President WFIRC,
S.R.M.Road, Kochi-682018, Kerala, India, Tel. 0484- 02993/9446572993, pkshamsuddin@rediffmail.com, and Fr. Albert Nambiaparambil
cmi, Secretary General, WFIRC, Upasana,Thodupuzha-685 584, Kerala,
India, Tel 04862-223286/9446131173, upasanadr@dataone.in & Upasana_dr@satyam.net.in
*October
17,
Featured speakers at the October kick-off event include Nobel Prize Winner Dr.
Muhammed Yunus, founder of Grameen Bank; the Honorable Dr. Fakhruddin Ahmed,
Chief Advisor, Dr. Kamal Hossain, principal author of the Bangladesh
Constitution; Reema Nanavaty, Director of the Self-Employed
Women's Association (SEWA) in
*November
29-30, Ambala Cantt,
www.writersclubinternational.org More info from
Dev Bhardwaj, Director, India
Inter-Continental Cultural Association, and Editor, Kafla Inter-Continental,
Chandigarh +91-98728-23437 & iicca@live.com
*December 3-9, 2009,
Melbourne, Australia: The 2009 Parliament of the World’s Religions, will bring together the world’s religious and spiritual communities,
their leaders and their followers to a gathering where peace, diversity and
sustainability are discussed and explored in the context of interreligious
understanding and cooperation.
Parliament
participants will work with others and within their own traditions to craft
faithful responses to indigenous reconciliation, global poverty and global
warming, environmental care and degradation, education of the young and the
challenges of social disengagement, voluntary and forced migration, artistic expression
and spirituality, the value of sports, ethnic and religious tensions. More
info from http://www.parliamentofreligions2009.org/home.php
FELLOWSHIPS
FOR JOURNALISTS FROM
*March 15 -
The 6th Senior
Journalists Seminar is a dialogue-and-travel program for journalists from the
Study Tour for
Asian Journalists:
Study Tour for
American Journalists:
The program
opens and concludes with dialogue among all the participants at the
Who Can
Apply: Working print, broadcast and online journalists with at least 10
years of experience from
Application
Deadline:
Funding:
Roundtrip airfare to travel destinations, all lodging and per diems are
provided. Participants are responsible for their own visa fees and roundtrip
airfare from their home city to
More
information and applications from www.eastwestcenter.org/journalismfellowships,
1-808-944-7176, & journalismfellowships@eastwestcenter.org
The
JOBS,
INTERNSHIPS & VOLUNTEER PROGRAMS (FOR THE COMMON GOOD)
http://www.graduationpledge.org/jobs.html
MEMBERS’
CORNER
*Dr.
Syed Akhtar Ehtisham’s book, “Medical Doctor Examines Life on Three
Continents Pakistani View,” will be published by Algora Publishing, this year.
The book has been described as a
sweeping narrative, which sketches the political and economic realities of the
past fifty years while tracing an eventful life from the turmoil following the
partition of
Dr. Ehtisham was born in
Anarchic conditions in
More info about the book can be
found at http://www.algora.com/258/book/details.html
PEACE & HARMONY NEWS FROM
*http://groups.yahoo.com/group/IndiaPakistanPeaceDay/
PEACE & HARMONY NEWS FROM
*http://groups.google.com/group/peace--harmony-news-from-south-asia
PEACE
PETITIONS
Dear World Leaders & Global
Organizations:
Be
advised: We, the ordinary citizens of this Earth will no longer fight, support,
or otherwise engage in war or mortal conflict of any sort.
More
info and signing at http://www.gopetition.co.uk/online/21655.html
UPDATE:
*http://groups.yahoo.com/group/KashmirSolutionsForum/
UPDATE:
*Beena Sarwar updates http://groups.yahoo.com/group/beena-issues/
*http://www.teeth.com.pk/blog/
UPDATE:
* Humanitarian
organisations have key role to play, Jehan Perera jehanpc@sltnet.lk (Executive Director, National Peace Council of Sri Lanka,
Colombo), September 12, 2008
During previous phases of the armed conflict successive governments have
obtained the assistance of both local and international humanitarian
organisations to ensure that essential supplies reach the affected people.
Humanitarian aid agencies in LTTE controlled territory have provided critical
support to the government by dispensing aid to both displaced and local
civilians living in those areas. The National Peace Council is concerned that
withdrawal of the humanitarian organisations will create a vacuum that the
government alone cannot fill. The humanitarian outlook will become extremely
bleak for those displaced and local civilians left behind.
The primary duty of any democratic government is to ensure the security and
sustenance of the people it governs. No section of the people, whether or not
they are under rebel control, can be excluded from this democratic duty. If
circumstances do not allow the government to fulfill this duty, it needs to
permit others to do so. The government needs to treat international
humanitarian agencies as its partners filling a void that it is unable to
fulfil. Their work needs to be facilitated and not curtailed.
The National Peace Council calls on the government to ensure that specialist
international agencies with a humanitarian mandate, such as the UNHCR and World
Food Programme that are specially trained to work in conflict zones, are
permitted to remain in the Vanni region where displaced and other war affected
people are living. If these organisations are prepared to take the risk of
continuing to work in war zones as part of their mandates, they need to be
supported and encouraged in this action. This includes cooperative approaches
to travel and visa applications and positive public messages of support for the
efforts of the UN and other humanitarian agencies.
The National Peace Council also calls on the LTTE to create a supportive
environment to assist humanitarian agencies to provide for the basic needs of
displaced people, by not removing their assets and equipment and diverting
humanitarian supplies. The LTTE also needs to ensure the safe and secure access
of humanitarian workers so that they may fulfill their humanitarian mandate.
The government and LTTE must also exercise restraint and take all necessary
precautions to ensure that civilians are not harmed as a result of their
fighting. This is the crux of International Humanitarian Law. We call on both
parties to cooperate with aid agencies to establish a humanitarian corridor so
that civilians can move to safety and access humanitarian assistance. Safe
movement should be guaranteed by the presence of
independent and neutral observers such as the ICRC.